Heritage Recipes

Sharing old family recipes and traditions

Egg Custard Pie
From Nancy

In loving memory of my grandmother,
Lettie Armstrong Glattli. 
Born 1902
Marion County, Florida
Died 1996
Polk County, Florida

Though I never learned to make Grandma's pie crust, Egg Custard Pie Recipe at Heritage Recipesantique aluminum pie pans from Wear-Ever and "homemade" piecrusts from Pillsbury allow me to make a perfectly acceptable version of her Egg Custard Pie.  Knowing this was my favorite, she always had an egg custard pie waiting for me whenever I came to visit.  Years after she died I took one of these egg custard pies to a church potluck dinner.  As they stood in line to fill their dinner plates, I observed two elderly men pointing to the dessert table.  One said to the other, "Is that a custard pie? I think that's a custard pie!"  As soon as they had filled their dinner plates the two men quickly set them down and headed back to the dessert table, each helping himself to a large slice of the egg custard pie.  I didn't see them return for second helpings, but by the time I reached the dessert table that night the pie was gone!  Had I known it would be so popular I would have made several of them.

Egg Custard Pie Recipe

4 eggs

2 cups milk

1 cup sugar

1 teaspoon vanilla



Stir eggs, milk, sugar and vanilla until well blended.  Pour into pie shell, sprinkle generously with nutmeg, and bake at 350 for 45-50 minutes or until set.

Depending on the quantities of ingredients she had on hand, Grandma sometimes used a small can of evaporated milk then added enough whole milk to this to equal two cups.  My mother varied the recipe slightly by using 1/2 teaspoon of vanilla and 1/2 teaspoon of lemon extract instead of the 1 teaspoon of vanilla.

Download PDF and Print Egg Custard Pie

Join us in sharing old family recipes and memories

Submit Your Heritage Recipe

www.heritagerecipes.com 2004-2016 | Home | New Recipes | Site Map  
Sharing Old Family Recipes, Traditions and Memories
   The majority recipes at Heritage Recipes have not been tested by us.   Share